Sam and Dean Winchester; two Midwest brothers on a quest to vanquish monsters, demons, and other forces of the paranormal. They've laid course to maintain the family business of saving people and hunting things that go bump in the night.
In a new and all-original episode, the brothers spend Thanksgiving together at a diner where Dean sustains a serious toothache from a slice of pecan pie and must have an emergency dental procedure. Sam makes a few phone calls and finds a dentist who will work on him in the late hours of the night – a dentist who is eerily cheery about Christmas and full of the spirit of the season.
Elsewhere in this sleepy little town, citizens are waking to find Christmas decorations strewn about their homes and businesses and the regular scrooges of the town have been found with gaping holes in their chests where their hearts should be. Law enforcement calls it an animal attack, but the Winchesters think there's something else afoot.
Will the Winchesters find out who is putting up Christmas decorations in the middle of the night? Will they discover who or what is leaving victims with gaping holes in their chests? Will Dean have his toothache cured from the cheerful dentist? Find out in this all-original episode of Supernatural: Live Parodies! Come hunting with us!